Monical’s Pizza Menu Prices (August 2026)

You can’t buy happiness. But you can buy pizza, and that’s kind of the same thing, especially if that pizza is coming from Monical’s!

Let’s face it – pizza is the ultimate comfort food and the solution to every problem! Whether you’re feeling sad, throwing a birthday party at the last minute, or simply too tired to cook dinner, you know you can always rely on that perfect slice of pizza to fix all your problems!

Now, when it comes to discovering where to get that perfect slice of pizza from, we have the answer for you – Monica’s Pizza Restaurant is the place for you!

It all started in Tolono, Illinois with the Monical family and their secret thin crust pizza recipe. Local friends and neighbors quickly discovered that life is not about finding yourself, it’s about finding the best pizza!

Now, there are over 60 Monical’s Pizza® restaurants, primarily located throughout Central Illinois with several in Indiana, one in Missouri, and one in Wisconsin. At Monical’s Pizza, you can order sandwiches, pastas, salads, desserts, and…the most delicious specialty pizzas in the Midwest!

Want a menu already? We have it right here, along with prices!

In this article

Monical’s Pizza Value Menu: Food Under $10
How Monical’s Pizza Compares
Full Monical’s Pizza Menu
Frequently Asked Questions
Monical’s Pizza Menu PDF

Monical’s Pizza Value Menu: Food Under $10

Soft Dough Bread Sticks: $4.50
Garden Fresh Salad: $4.75
8" (Individual) Thin Crust Cheese Pizza: $8.00
Mozzarella Sticks: $8.50
Pepperollies: $8.50
8" (Individual) Pan Cheese Pizza: $9.00

How Monical’s Pizza Compares

Chain	Typical item price	Cheapest main	Items tracked	Updated
Gionino's Pizzeria	$5.69	Single Tender $2.30	91	August 2026
Pieology	$5.75	11" Cheese Original Thin $9.20	47	August 2026
Hungry Howie's	$10.15	Howie Roll $5.05	111	July 2026
Monical’s Pizza	$11.00	8" (Individual) Thin Crust Cheese Pizza $8.00	36	August 2026
Pizza Inn	$11.29	–	43	August 2026
Ledo's Pizza	$11.49	Plain $6.89	131	August 2026
Pizza Express	$12.00	Fried Egg Sandwich Breakfast $5.00	277	August 2026
Mazzios	$14.99	Spaghetti $8.49	93	August 2026

Prices are from each chain's benchmark location; see each page for full menus. And 2 more pizza chains.

Pizzas

Item	Price
14" (Medium) Thin Crust Cheese PizzaA 14-inch thin crust pizza topped with a blend of melted cheeses and a hint of tomato sauce.	$18.50
12" (Small) Thin Crust Cheese PizzaCrispy thin crust topped with melted mozzarella cheese and a hint of tomato sauce.	$14.00
16" (Large) Thin Crust Cheese PizzaA large, thin crust pizza topped with a generous layer of melted cheese and a hint of tomato sauce.	$22.00
8" (Individual) Thin Crust Cheese PizzaA crispy thin crust topped with melted mozzarella cheese and a tangy tomato sauce.	$8.00
16" (Large) Thin Crust Cheese Pizza Family Pleaser16" thin crust pizza, served with a family garden salad and 2 liter of soda.	$32.00
10" (Small) Pan Cheese PizzaA small pan pizza with a thick crust, topped with melted cheese and a rich tomato sauce.	$14.00
14" (Large) Pan Cheese PizzaA large 14-inch pan pizza topped with melted mozzarella cheese, rich tomato sauce, and a sprinkle of herbs.	$22.00
8" (Individual) Pan Cheese PizzaGenerously topped with melted mozzarella cheese and a rich tomato sauce on a thick, golden crust.	$9.00
8" (Individual) Pan Cheese Individual Pleaser8" pan pizza, served with an individual salad and 20 oz soft drink.	$14.50
14" (Medium) Thin Crust Cheese Pizza Family Pleaser14" thin crust pizza, served with a family garden salad and 2 liter of soda.	$28.50
14" (Large) Pan Cheese Pizza Family Pleaser14" pan pizza served with a family garden salad and 2 liter of soda.	$32.00
8" (Individual) Thin Crust Cheese Individual Pleaser8" thin crust pizza, served with individual garden salad and a 20 oz soft drink.	$13.50

The cheapest Pizzas item is the 8" (Individual) Thin Crust Cheese Pizza at $8.00. Prices run to $32.00 across 12 priced items at this Fishers location.

Specialty Pizzas

Item	Price
Deluxe PizzaSausage, pepperoni, mushrooms, onions, green olives, green bell peppers, and hot pepperoncini.	$11.00
Buffalo Chicken PizzaSpicy buffalo chicken, ranch dressing, and premium blend cheese.	$11.00
Mighty Meat PizzaSausage, ham, pepperoni, and bacon.	$11.00
Veggie PizzaMushrooms, onions, green bell peppers, black olives, tomatoes, and premium blend cheese.	$12.00
Italian Special PizzaSausage, mushrooms, onions, green olives, and hot pepperoncini.	$11.00
Delight PizzaSausage, pepperoni, mushrooms, onions, and green bell peppers.	$11.00
BBQ Chicken PizzaSeasoned chicken, BBQ sauce, and premium blend cheese.	$11.00

The Deluxe Pizza is the lowest-priced Specialty Pizzas item at $11.00 at this Fishers location. The 7 priced items range up to $12.00.

Starters

Item	Price
Soft Dough Bread SticksServed with a choice of marinara, garlic sauce, nacho, or mild Cheddar. Additional 3 oz dipping sauce for an additional charge.	$4.50
Garlic Cheese Bread8 slices of toasted garlic sweet bread topped with mozzarella cheese. Served with 3 oz marinara.	$8.50
PepperolliesFresh-baked rolls with zesty pepperoni, rich purée, and 4 kinds of cheese. Seasoned with a hint of garlic and served with marinara.	$8.50
Hot WingsServed with ranch or bleu cheese dressing.	$11.00
Mozzarella SticksOrder of 5. Mozzarella dipped in Parmesan and Romano breading and then baked. Served with 3 oz marinara.	$8.50

The cheapest Starters item is the Soft Dough Bread Sticks at $4.50. The 5 priced items top out at $11.00 at this Fishers location.

Salads

Item	Price
Garden Fresh SaladFresh lettuce with tomatoes, shredded carrots, and Colby cheese.	$4.75
Pecan Grilled Chicken SaladGrilled chicken with romaine lettuce, red bell pepper, red onion, toasted pecans, and shredded Parmesan cheese. This item contains nuts. Served with 1 soft dough bread stick.	$12.00

The two Salads items are Garden Fresh Salad at $4.75 and Pecan Grilled Chicken Salad at $12.00 at this Fishers location.

Sandwiches

Item	Price
Hot Sicilian SandwichSweet roll, sliced ham, bacon, pepperoni, melted mozzarella, and lettuce with dijonnaise mustard.	$10.50
Chicken Bacon Ranch SandwichSweet roll layered with ranch dressing topped with seasoned grilled chicken, bacon, and mozzarella.	$10.50
Buffalo Chicken SandwichSeasoned chicken smothered in buffalo sauce topped with ranch dressing and mozzarella served on a sweet roll.	$10.50
Ham and Cheese SandwichSliced ham topped with melted American cheese served on a sweet roll.	$10.50
Turkey SubSweet roll, sliced turkey combined with lettuce, tomato, mozzarella, and dijonnaise mustard.	$10.50
BBQ Chicken SandwichGrilled chicken with BBQ sauce and topped with melted mozzarella.	$10.50

Every Sandwiches item is $10.50: all 6 cost the same at this Fishers location.

Pastas

Item	Price
Spaghetti with MarinaraA healthy portion of spaghetti with marinara.	$10.50
Cheese TortelliniA generous portion of cheese-filled tortellini topped with rich marinara.	$10.50

The two Pastas items are Cheese Tortellini at $10.50 and Spaghetti with Marinara at $10.50 at this Fishers location.

Beverages

Item	Price
Soft DrinkCoke, Diet Coke, Sprite, Root Beer.	$3.50

The only Beverages item is Soft Drink at $3.50 at this Fishers location.

Take Some Home

Item	Price
Sweet and Tart DressingAvailable in a 5 oz container or 18 oz squeeze bottle.	$1.25

The only Take Some Home item is Sweet and Tart Dressing at $1.25 at this Fishers location.

Frequently Asked Questions

How much is the 14" (Medium) Thin Crust Cheese Pizza at Monical’s Pizza?

The 14" (Medium) Thin Crust Cheese Pizza costs $18.50 at Monical’s Pizza as of August 2026 – one of 12 items in the Pizzas section.

What is the cheapest meal-worthy item at Monical’s Pizza?

Setting aside condiments, drinks and extras, the cheapest meal-worthy item on the Monical’s Pizza menu is the 8" (Individual) Thin Crust Cheese Pizza at $8.00 as of August 2026.

What is the price range at Monical’s Pizza?

Prices on the Monical’s Pizza menu run from $1.25 to $32.00 as of August 2026, counting everything on the page from single sides up to family-size and catering orders, and half the priced items are $11.00 or less.

How many items are on the Monical’s Pizza menu?

The Monical’s Pizza menu we track lists 36 items across 8 sections as of August 2026.

Does Monical’s Pizza have a value menu?

Yes: 6 items under $10 as of August 2026, starting with the Soft Dough Bread Sticks at $4.50. See the value list above.

Monical’s Pizza Menu PDF

Download the full Monical’s Pizza menu with prices as a PDF: Monical’s Pizza Menu Prices PDF (updated August 2026).

Monical’s Pizza Menu & Price