SusieCakes is a beloved All-American bakery offering classic desserts like cupcakes, cakes, puddings, cookies, and pies. What really makes SusieCakes so different from the rest of the bakeries is the fact that all desserts are made entirely from scratch using simple and natural ingredients. Just like our grandmothers, SusieCakes’ pastry chefs don’t use any ready store-bought mixes or artificial preservatives, making it the perfect place for those looking for delicious, sentimental sweets and a friendly, old-fashioned neighborhood experience.
If you love cake and believe that cakes should not be reserved for special occasions only, a slice of cake from SusieCakes will immediately bring a bit of celebration to your ordinary day. Susie’s famous Southern Red Velvet cake or everyone’s favorite Old-Fashioned 6-Layer Chocolate Cake are just some of the delightful cakes you can get from SusieCakes. Customers can also enjoy cupcakes, pies, and cookies of all shapes, sizes, and flavors, baked with love and dedication.
Want to see more of Susie Cakes’ menu? We have it right here, along with updated prices.
In this article
Prices updated August 16, 2026. Prices are from the chain's delivery menu; in-store prices are often lower. Keep in mind that prices vary a lot depending on where you are, and you might not pay what we paid.
How Susie Cakes Compares
| Chain | Typical item price | Cheapest main | Items tracked | Updated |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Crumbl Cookies | $2.29 | – | 55 | July 2026 |
| Duck Donuts | $4.20 | Bacon in the Sun $4.20 | 108 | July 2026 |
| Philly Pretzel Factory | $4.50 | Mini Pretzels – 1 Row $4.20 | 52 | July 2026 |
| BoSa Donuts | $5.69 | Bacon, Egg, and Cheese Sandwich $6.49 | 112 | July 2026 |
| Auntie Anne's | $5.99 | Cinnamon Sugar Pretzel $6.99 | 44 | July 2026 |
| Cinnabon | $6.19 | – | 42 | July 2026 |
| Krispy Kreme | $9.69 | – | 49 | July 2026 |
| Susie Cakes | $19.80 | – | 49 | August 2026 |
Prices are from each chain's benchmark location; see each page for full menus. And 2 more donut and dessert chains.
Full Susie Cakes Menu
PIE | Fresh Baked Cupcakes | Cookies & Bars | Cakes | Party Favors
PIE
| Item | Price |
|---|---|
| Key Lime Pie SliceSEASONAL. Made with fresh key lime juice, baked on a graham cracker crust, and topped with freshly whipped cream. Available through 9/7. | $7.80 |
| Key Lime PieSEASONAL. Made with fresh key lime juice, baked on a graham cracker crust, and topped with freshly whipped cream. Available through 9/7. | $41.95 |
The two PIE items are Key Lime Pie Slice at $7.80 and Key Lime Pie at $41.95.
Fresh Baked Cupcakes
| Item | Price |
|---|---|
| Susie's PupCake 4-boxFOR DOG CONSUMPTION. Celebrate Dog Days of Summer! $1 from every Susie's PupCake sold goes to local shelters and rescue groups. Four banana and peanut butter cupcakes, frosted with peanut butter whipped cream. Available through 8/31. | $25.20 |
| Raspberry Vanilla Cupcake 4-boxSEASONAL. Four Madagascar vanilla cupcakes baked with fresh raspberries, frosted with velvety vanilla buttercream. Available through 9/7. | $27.60 |
| 4 Box Cupcake AssortmentBaked from scratch, daily in our on-site kitchen. Decorations may change depending on season or holiday. | $25.20 |
| 8 Box Cupcake AssortmentBaked from scratch, daily in our on-site kitchen. Decorations may change depending on season or holiday. | $50.40 |
| 12 Box Cupcake AssortmentBaked from scratch, daily in our on-site kitchen. Decorations may change depending on season or holiday. | $75.60 |
| Happy Birthday Cupcake 4 BoxRed Velvet Cupcake/Cream Cheese Frosting, Vanilla Cupcake/SusieBlue Buttercream, Chocolate Cupcake/Vanilla Buttercream, Chocolate Cupcake/Chocolate Buttercream.Decorations may change depending on season or holiday. | $30.00 |
| Happy Birthday Cupcake Dozen BoxOne dozen cupcakes – assorted chocolate, vanilla & red velvet, personally inscribed for a birthday celebration! | $90.00 |
| Thank You Cupcake 4 BoxThank – Chocolate Cupcake/Vanilla ButtercreamYou – Chocolate Cupcake/Chocolate ButtercreamSo – Vanilla Cupcake/SusieBlue ButtercreamMuch! – Red Velvet Cupcake/Cream Cheese Frosting | $30.00 |
| Mini Cupcake Assorted Dozen BoxBite-sized cupcakes, baked from scratch daily! Perfect for parties, celebrations, kids’ birthdays, or anytime you want an easy-to-share treat. Available in Red Velvet, Vanilla, Chocolate, and Flourless Chocolate dozen boxes. | $43.05 |
The Susie's PupCake 4-box is the lowest-priced Fresh Baked Cupcakes item at $25.20. The 9 priced items range up to $90.00.
Cookies & Bars
| Item | Price |
|---|---|
| Dog Frosted Sugar Cookie 4-boxCelebrate Dog Days of Summer! $1 from every dog cookie sold goes to local shelters and rescue groups. Four dog-shaped sugar cookies frosted in royal icing, dipped in sanding sugar. Comes with two white, one brown and one golden dog, but may vary due to bakery availability. Not for animal consumption. Available through 8/31. | $28.60 |
| Dog Frosted Sugar Cookie PlatterCelebrate Dog Days of Summer! $1 from every dog cookie sold goes to local shelters and rescue groups. 18 dog-shaped sugar cookies frosted in royal icing, dipped in sanding sugar. Comes with 6 white, 6 brown and 6 golden dogs. Not for animal consumption. Available through 8/31. | $128.52 |
| Susie's Famous Dog TreatsFOR DOG CONSUMPTION. Two dozen dog treats (24) for your furry friend. Our special recipe combines peanut butter, flour, eggs, and molasses that will make your pooch's tail wag with joy! Available through 8/31. | $15.54 |
| Whoopie Pies 4-boxSEASONAL. A Susie exclusive! Four Whoopie Pies, each consisting of two thick, chewy chocolate cookies sandwiched with vanilla buttercream. Available through 9/7. | $38.16 |
| Chocolate Chip Cookies 4-boxEveryone’s favorite classic! Four soft, buttery cookies baked with brown sugar and plenty of semi-sweet chocolate chips. | $19.15 |
| Snickerdoodle Cookie 4-boxOur snickerdoodle cookies are classic! Characterized by their pillowy texture and irresistible cinnamon-sugar coating, these cookies have a slightly crispy exterior and a soft, tender center, making them a true crowd-pleaser. | $19.15 |
| Flourless Peanut Butter Cookies 4-boxFour soft and chewy peanut butter cookie made without gluten. *Please note, there is gluten present in the bakery and in other products, and we do share equipment among products. | $18.00 |
| Susie's Nutty 4-boxCalling all peanut butter lovers! Two flourless peanut butter cookies sandwiched together with creamy peanut butter buttercream for the ultimate peanut butter treat. Box includes four Susie’s Nutty Sandwich Cookies.*Please note, there is gluten present in the bakery and in other products, and we do share equipment among products. | $38.15 |
| Take & Bake: Chocolate Chip Cookie DoughBake and save! Our classic chocolate chip cookie dough is now available in convenient 12-count packs. Just pop them in the oven and enjoy warm, freshly baked cookies anytime. | $43.18 |
The cheapest Cookies & Bars item is the Susie's Famous Dog Treats at $15.54. The 9 priced items top out at $128.52.
Cakes
| Item | Price |
|---|---|
| Lemon Poppyseed LoafSEASONAL. Lemon loaf made with real lemon juice, lemon zest, and poppyseeds, topped with a fresh lemon glaze. Serves 8. Available through 9/7. | $23.98 |
| Summer Strawberry Whip CakeSEASONAL. Madagascar vanilla sponge cake, layered with fresh strawberries, filled & frosted with fresh whipped cream. Available through 9/7. | $83.98 |
| Celebration Cake6-layers of vanilla cake baked with colorful sugar confetti, filled & frosted with our signature retro-blue vanilla frosting. | $71.98 |
| Old-Fashioned Chocolate Cake“Just like you remember!” Towering high, moist chocolate cake filled and covered in rich, dark chocolate buttercream frosting. | $71.98 |
| Southern Red Velvet CakeDeep red, moist cake lightly flavored with cocoa, filled & topped with traditional cream cheese frosting. Our best seller! | $65.98 |
| Classic Marble CakeVanilla and chocolate cake marbled together with chocolate chips. Filled and frosted with vanilla and chocolate buttercreams. | $65.98 |
| Carrot CakeBaked with pecans & golden raisins, layered with our unique “praline filling” & topped with traditional cream cheese frosting. | $65.98 |
| 2 Specialty Cake SlicesPick two decadent slices of our handcrafted specialty cakes. Each slice is made with premium ingredients and unique flavor combinations, perfect for treating yourself or sharing a sweet moment with someone special. | $19.80 |
The cheapest Cakes item is the 2 Specialty Cake Slices at $19.80, and prices reach $83.98 across 8 priced items.
Party Favors
| Item | Price |
|---|---|
| Gold PlatesMake your guests feel special with food served on these glimmering gold paper dinner plates. Made from high-quality card with a superb gloss finish. Pack of 8. Product dimensions: 6.25 x 6.25 inches | $10.74 |
| Gold Stripe NapkinsAdd an elegant touch to your meal with these beautiful, yet practical, napkins with gorgeous glimmery gold foil stripes and a textured border. Made from top quality thick ply paper. 16 napkins. Folded dimensions: 5 x 5 inches | $9.00 |
| Happy Birthday Stars PlatesYou're a star! Celebrate a special someone's birthday with these gorgeous paper plates. Our Happy Birthday tableware features colorful stars, teamed with shiny gold, perfect to complement any birthday party color theme. Pack of 8. Product dimensions: 10.5 x 10.5 x 0.25 inches | $10.74 |
| Happy Birthday Stars NapkinsYou're a star and deserve special party tableware that lets everyone know it! These scalloped, colorful Happy Birthday napkins are perfect to celebrate your big day. The small size is ideal for kids or cocktail parties. 16 napkins. Folded dimensions: 5 x 5 inches | $9.00 |
| Summer Sky Blue PlatesMake your party table look dreamy with these summer sky blue side paper plates. They're beautifully designed with the color on the front and back, and an octagonal shape for an eye-catching look. They're perfect for a baby shower, birthday parties or to give any dinner party a cool, calm vibe. Pack of 8. Product dimensions: 8.25 x 8.25 x 0.25 inches | $10.74 |
| Summer Sky Blue NapkinsMake your party table look really dreamy with these summer sky blue napkins. They're perfect for a baby shower, birthday parties or to give any dinner party a cool, calm vibe. 16 napkins. Folded dimensions: 5 x 5 inches | $9.00 |
| Mixed Happy Birthday PlatesYou can never say “Happy Birthday” too many times, so let these special paper side plates spell it out for you! This set contains a rainbow of colors to brighten any birthday party, and beautifully complement the rest of your birthday party supplies. Each octagonal plate also has a co-ordinating colored border, and color on the reverse, to add extra style to the celebrations. Pack of 8. 8.5 x 8.5 x 0.25 inches | $10.74 |
| Mixed Happy Birthday NapkinsYou can never say “Happy Birthday” too many times, so let these special paper napkins spell it out for you! This set contains a rainbow of colors to brighten up any birthday party, and beautifully complement the rest of your birthday party supplies. Each napkin also has a co-ordinating colored border to add extra style to the celebrations. 16 napkins. Folded dimensions: 5 x 5 inches | $9.00 |
| Rocco Pink PlatesInspired by classic elegance, these pastel pink side plates feature white rococo-inspired patterns, wavy vintage-style edges, and delicate pearl accents. A matching pink reverse completes the look for a beautifully coordinated table. Perfect for alfresco lunches, high teas, and spring celebrations like baby or bridal showers. Pack of 8. Product dimensions: 9.25 x 9.25 x 0.25 inches | $10.74 |
| Rocco Pink NapkinsInspired by classic elegance, these pastel pink napkins feature white rococo-style patterns, wavy edges, and delicate pearl-like accents. Perfect for alfresco lunches, teas, and spring celebrations, they add a refined touch to any gathering. 16 napkins. Folded dimensions: 5 x 5 inches | $9.00 |
| Gold Happy Birthday CandleThis gorgeous gold "Happy Birthday" candle is the perfect decoration for a special birthday cake. Featuring two wicks so you can light up the cake in style. Candle height (includes stick) – 4 inches | $11.40 |
| Gold Number CandleAvailable in numbers 0 through 9, these die-cut number candles are perfect for any celebration! Number candles are perfect for birthdays, anniversaries and celebrations. One candle per package. 3 3/8" inches tall. | $5.94 |
| Sparkler Number CandleWhile putting candles on the cake is all very well and good, we're going one step better with these sparkler candles! Decorated with gold glitter, these candles will truly stand out! Choose between numbers 0-9. Sparkler height (includes stick) – 7.25 inches | $7.80 |
| Glitter Dipped CandlesThese gorgeous two-tone glittery candles will look really impressive on a special celebration cake. Your choice of Gold, Pale Pink, or Silver. Pack of 16. Candle height – 5.75 inches | $15.00 |
| Mini Taper Birthday CandlesThese charming birthday candle packs are available in a variety of festive color palettes. Each container includes 20 miniature taper-style birthday candles that give cakes and cupcakes elegant and whimsical flair. Container of 20 Birthday Candles. 3.75" long. | $10.20 |
| Slim Birthday CandlesThese charming slim birthday candle packs are available in a variety of festive colors. Each container includes 16 slim-style birthday candles that give cakes and cupcakes elegant and whimsical flair. Set of 16 Candles. 6in long. | $11.40 |
| Party Confetti BoxThis luxury tissue confetti, in a range of beautiful rich colors, is exactly what you need to add extra fun and brightness to any occasion. Round confetti in 7 colors. Pack dimensions: 4 x 3.75 x 1.75 inches | $9.60 |
| Party HatsWhat better way to celebrate another excellent year than presenting your guests with these fabulously bright and sparkly party hats to wear! Each one comes in an individual color, finished with a band of gorgeous glitter. Pack of 8 in 8 colors. Product dimensions: 3.75 x 5.625 x 3.75 inches | $24.00 |
| Mini Party HatsWhat better way to celebrate another excellent year than presenting your guests with these fabulously bright and sparkly party hats to wear! Each one comes in an individual color, finished with a band of gorgeous glitter. Pack of 8 in 8 colors. Product dimensions: 3.75 x 5.625 x 3.75 inches | $20.40 |
| BlowersWhether you're throwing a party for little kids or big ones, you can't go wrong with these brilliant party blowers – they're the sort of fun you never grow out of! Each blower is decorated with a stripe pattern in individual colors, embellished with gold glitter. Pack of 8 in 8 colors. Pack dimensions: 5.5 x 5 x 0.75 inches | $12.00 |
| Greeting CardSend a thoughtful message with these letterpress printed greeting cards. These all come with blank interiors that lets you add your own personal touch. Hand printed in Los Angeles by Sugar Paper LA. | $8.40 |
The cheapest Party Favors item is the Gold Number Candle at $5.94. Prices run to $24.00 across 21 priced items.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the price range at Susie Cakes?
Prices on the Susie Cakes menu run from $5.94 to $128.52 as of August 2026, counting everything on the page from single sides up to family-size and catering orders, and half the priced items are $19.80 or less.
How many items are on the Susie Cakes menu?
The Susie Cakes menu we track lists 49 items across 5 sections as of August 2026.
Susie Cakes Menu PDF
Download the full Susie Cakes menu with prices as a PDF: Susie Cakes Menu Prices PDF (updated August 2026).
