Pickleman's Menu Prices (August 2026)

Best Value Picks

Most protein per dollar: #6 Asiago Chicken Sandwich – 50g protein at $10.65.
Lightest meal-worthy item: #9 Italian Beef Sandwich – 480 calories at $10.98.
Cheapest 1,000 calories: #16 Grilled Cheese Sandwich – about $12.00 per 1,000 calories ($7.68, 640 cal).

Pickleman's Value Menu: Food Under $5

Hard-Boiled Egg: $1.08
Soup Roll: $1.08
Sliced Avocado: $1.41
Giardiniera Peppers: $1.52
Cheese: $1.96
Wheat Bread: $2.18
White Bread: $2.18
Chips: $2.40
In Store Chips: $2.40
Meat: $2.51
Half & Half 10" Gluten Friendly: $3.30
Chicken Salad: $4.60

How Pickleman's Compares

Chain	Typical item price	Cheapest main	Items tracked	Updated
Arby's	$4.79	Buffalo Chicken Slider $2.89	68	July 2026
Blimpie	$5.99	Buffalo Chicken $4.99	49	July 2026
Quiznos	$6.72	Chipotle Turkey $6.12	52	July 2026
Potbelly	$6.79	Grilled Cheese $8.49	80	July 2026
Panera Bread	$6.99	Grilled Cheese $8.19	211	July 2026
Pita Pit	$7.00	Awakin with Bacon Pita $7.00	35	July 2026
Charley's Philly Steaks	$7.19	Chicken Buffalo $8.19	47	August 2026
Pickleman's	$8.78	Half & Half 10" Gluten Friendly $3.30	86	August 2026

Prices are from each chain's benchmark location; see each page for full menus. And 30 more sandwich and sub chains.

Toasted Sandwiches

Item	Price	Cal	Protein (g)	Carbs (g)	Fat (g)
#11 Italian Club SandwichGenoa salami, capicola, pepperoni, ham, provolone, lettuce, tomato, onion, mayo, V&O, & Italian seasoning	$10.98	910	41	70	45
#5 Turkey Bacon Club SandwichTurkey, bacon, provolone, lettuce, tomato, & mayo	$10.43	800	43	69	37
#9 Italian Beef SandwichItalian beef dipped in au jus, with giardiniera peppers	$10.98	480	34	61	10
#1 Turkey SandwichTurkey, provolone, lettuce, tomato, & mayo	$9.11	640	31	69	25
#17 Chipotle Chicken SandwichChicken, provolone, lettuce, & chipotle ranch	$10.65	750	44	70	32
#7 Hodge Podge SandwichSalami, capicola, turkey, ham, provolone, lettuce, tomato, & mayo	$12.08	870	52	71	41
#6 Asiago Chicken SandwichChicken, bacon, provolone, & Asiago Caesar dressing	$10.65	860	50	69	42
#8 Cafe Club SandwichHam, turkey, provolone, lettuce, tomato, & mayo	$10.43	710	41	70	28
#15 Buffalo Chicken SandwichChicken, provolone, buffalo sauce, crumbled bleu cheese, lettuce, & ranch	$10.65	–	–	–	–
#16 Grilled Cheese SandwichMozzarella & provolone	$7.68	640	32	64	26
Sandwich Combo MealAdd chips and a drink to your favorite sandwich!	$11.38	–	–	–	–
#2 Ham SandwichHam, provolone, lettuce, tomato, & mayo	$8.78	640	29	67	28
#3 Veggie SandwichExtra provolone, cucumbers, avocado, lettuce, tomato, & mayo	$8.45	640	29	67	28
#4 Chicken Salad SandwichChicken salad, provolone, & lettuce [Contains nuts]	$9.88	740	31	77	31
#12 Smokehouse Stack SandwichPulled pork, bacon, provolone, onions, lettuce, & chipotle ranch	$12.08	970	51	71	51
#13 B.L.T.C SandwichBacon, provolone, lettuce, tomato, & mayo	$9.88	–	–	–	–
#14 BBQ Pulled Pork SandwichPulled pork, provolone, pickles, onions, & BBQ sauce	$12.08	–	–	–	–
Half SandwichesHalf of our whole toasted sandwiches	$5.48	–	–	–	–
#10 Cuban SandwichPulled pork, ham, provolone, pickles, & yellow mustard	$12.08	720	48	66	28

The cheapest Toasted Sandwiches item is the Half Sandwiches at $5.48. Prices run to $12.08 across 19 priced items. Best protein per dollar: #6 Asiago Chicken Sandwich at 50g for $10.65.

Pizzas

Item	Price
Pepperoni PizzaMarinara, cheese blend, & pepperoni	$15.93
Cheese PizzaClassic cheese blend and marinara	$13.73
Italian Sausage PizzaMarinara, cheese blend & Italian sausage	$15.93
Veggie PizzaMarinara, cheese blend, spinach, giardiniera peppers, black olives, & tomatoes	$16.48
Asiago Chicken PizzaChicken, crumbled bacon, cheese blend, & Asiago Caesar dressing	$19.78
BBQ Chicken PizzaChicken, cheese blend & BBQ sauce	$19.78
Buffalo Chicken PizzaChicken, cheese blend, bleu cheese crumbles, & buffalo sauce	$19.78
The Hog PizzaPepperoni, sausage, chicken, marinara, cheese blend, giardiniera peppers, & onions	$21.98
The Truth PizzaChicken, cheese blend, buffalo sauce, bleu cheese crumbles, topped with BBQ Sauce	$20.88
Chipotle Beef PizzaItalian beef, pepperoni, cheese blend, & chipotle ranch	$21.98
Half & Half 12" Regular	$14.84
Half & Half 10" Gluten Friendly	$3.30

The Half & Half 10" Gluten Friendly is the lowest-priced Pizzas item at $3.30. The 12 priced items range up to $21.98.

Salads

Item	Price
Asiago Caesar SaladRomaine, parmesan, Asiago Caesar dressing & croutons	$6.58
Avo-Cobb SaladRomaine, sliced avocado, crumbled bacon, hard-boiled egg, tomatoes, shredded cheddar & croutons	$8.78
Buffalo Chicken SaladRomaine, chicken tossed in buffalo sauce, bleu cheese crumbles, shredded cheese blend, onions, tomatoes, & croutons	$8.78
Cafe Chop SaladRomaine, turkey, ham, shredded cheddar, tomatoes, cucumbers, & croutons	$8.78
Garden Chop SaladRomaine, shredded cheddar, tomatoes, cucumbers, banana peppers, black olives, & croutons	$7.68
Italian Chop SaladRomaine, salami, capicola, ham, shredded cheese blend, tomatoes, giardiniera peppers, banana peppers, onions, black olives, & croutons	$8.78
Walnut Cran SaladSpinach, cranberries, walnuts, bleu cheese crumbles, & hard-boiled egg	$8.78

The cheapest Salads item is the Asiago Caesar Salad at $6.58. The 7 priced items top out at $8.78.

Mac & Cheese

Item	Price
Mac & CheeseWhite cheddar mac & cheese topped with grated parmesan	$6.58
Chicken Bacon Ranch Mac & Cheese BowlChicken, crumbled bacon, & ranch over mac & cheese	$9.88
Buffalo Chicken Mac & Cheese BowlChicken, crumbled bleu cheese, buffalo sauce, & ranch over mac & cheese	$9.88
Chipotle Chicken Mac & Cheese BowlsChicken, giardiniera peppers, & chipotle ranch over mac & cheese	$9.88
BBQ Pulled Pork Mac & Cheese BowlsPulled pork and BBQ sauce over mac & cheese	$9.88
Spicy Pork Mac & Cheese BowlsPulled pork, giardiniera peppers, & chipotle ranch over mac & cheese	$9.88

The cheapest Mac & Cheese item is the Mac & Cheese at $6.58, and prices reach $9.88 across 6 priced items.

Soups

Item	Price
8oz Broccoli Cheese8 ounces of rich and tangy cheddar cheese soup with fresh broccoli	$6.58
8oz Tomato Basil Bisque8 ounces of our signature creamy tomato bisque	$6.58
12oz Tomato Basil Bisque12 ounces of our signature creamy tomato bisque	$8.78
12 oz Broccoli Cheese12 ounces of rich and tangy cheddar cheese soup with fresh broccoli	$8.78
Soup RollHalf a loaf of our all natural white bread	$1.08

The cheapest Soups item is the Soup Roll at $1.08. Prices run to $8.78 across 5 priced items.

Sides

Item	Price
ChipsBoulder Canyon non-GMO kettle-cooked chips	$2.40
Garlic Cheese BreadGarlic butter & mozzarella cheese on white bread with a side of marinara topped with parmesan and Italian seasoning	$8.78
PickleGrillo's Pickles, available in whole or half	$0.86
Chocolate Chip CookieFresh cookies made from scratch daily	$1.63
Dozen CookiesChocolate chip cookies made from scratch daily	$14.28
Chicken SaladHouse made chicken salad (Contains Nuts)	$4.60
Dressings & SaucesVariety of house made dressings & signature sauces	$1.08
MeatSide portion of meat	$2.51
CheeseSide portion of cheese	$1.96
Giardiniera PeppersSide of our spicy giardiniera	$1.52
Jar of PeppersTake home a jar of Pickleman’s spicy giardiniera peppers!	$10.98
Avocado Spread3oz side of our smooth avocado spread	$1.41
Sliced Avocado1/4 of a fresh avocado	$1.41
Croutons3oz croutons	$0.42
Hard-Boiled EggWhole egg cut in half	$1.08
In Store Chips	$2.40
White BreadWhole loaf of our natural white bread	$2.18
Wheat BreadWhole loaf of our natural wheat bread	$2.18
NapkinsNapkins	–
Extra Walnuts or Cranberries	$2.18
Apple Sauce	$2.18

The Croutons is the lowest-priced Sides item at $0.42. The 20 priced items range up to $14.28. The section lists 21 items, 20 with prices.

Item	Price
Kids TurkeyTurkey, provolone, lettuce, tomato, & mayo	$8.23
Kids HamHam, provolone, lettuce, tomato, & mayo	$8.23
Kids Grilled CheeseMozzarella & Provolone	$8.23
Kids Mac & CheeseWhite cheddar mac & cheese topped with grated parmesan	$9.33
Kids Pizza GuyMarinara, mozzarella, pepperoni, Italian seasoning, & Parmesan	$8.23

The cheapest Kids Menu item is the Kids Turkey at $8.23. The 5 priced items top out at $9.33.

Beverages

Item	Price
Fountain BeverageCoke Products	$3.28
Sweet Iced TeaFresh Brewed with Pure Cane Sugar	$3.28
Strawberry LemonadeNon-GMO Lemons, Pure Cane Sugar, Water & Strawberry Puree	$3.28
LemonadeNon-GMO Lemons, Pure Cane Sugar & Water	$3.28
Unsweet Iced TeaOrganic Rishi Black Tea	$3.28
Half & Half TeaHalf Sweet & Half Unsweet Tea	$3.28
Bottled WaterNatural Spring Water	$3.28
Apple JuiceHonest Kids Organic Apple Juice	$3.28
White MilkHorizon Organic White Milk	$3.28
Powerade	$3.28
Water Cups	$0.27

The cheapest Beverages item is the Water Cups at $0.27, and prices reach $3.28 across 11 priced items.

Frequently Asked Questions

How much is the #15 Buffalo Chicken Sandwich at Pickleman's?

The #15 Buffalo Chicken Sandwich costs $10.65 at Pickleman's as of August 2026 – one of 19 items in the Toasted Sandwiches section.

What is the cheapest meal-worthy item at Pickleman's?

Setting aside condiments, drinks and extras, the cheapest meal-worthy item on the Pickleman's menu is the Half & Half 10" Gluten Friendly at $3.30 as of August 2026.

What is the price range at Pickleman's?

Prices on the Pickleman's menu run from $0.27 to $21.98 as of August 2026, counting everything on the page from single sides up to family-size and catering orders, and half the priced items are $8.78 or less.

How many items are on the Pickleman's menu?

The Pickleman's menu we track lists 86 items across 8 sections as of August 2026.

What is the lightest meal-worthy item at Pickleman's?

#9 Italian Beef Sandwich is the lightest meal-worthy item at 480 calories, priced $10.98 as of August 2026.

What's the cheapest way to get 40g of protein at Pickleman's?

#5 Turkey Bacon Club Sandwich delivers 43g of protein for $10.43 as of August 2026.

What's the most food you can get at Pickleman's for under $10?

#4 Chicken Salad Sandwich, 740 calories for $9.88, is the biggest single order under $10 as of August 2026.

Does Pickleman's have a value menu?

Yes: 12 items under $5 as of August 2026, starting with the Hard-Boiled Egg at $1.08. See the value list above.

Pickleman’s Menu PDF

Download the full Pickleman’s menu with prices as a PDF: Pickleman’s Menu Prices PDF (updated August 2026).

Pickleman’s Menu & Prices