In this article
Prices updated July 30, 2026. Prices sourced from 2025 N Tustin St, Orange, CA, 92865, US. Prices are from the chain's delivery menu at this location; in-store prices are often lower. Keep in mind that prices vary a lot depending on where you are, and you might not pay what we paid.
Polly's Pies Value Menu: Food Under $10
- Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip: $2.19
- Green Beans: $3.29
- Polly's Coleslaw: $3.29
- Cornbread: $3.59
- Cottage Cheese: $3.59
- French Baguette: $3.59
- Fresh Fruit: $3.59
- Fruit Cup: $3.59
- Macaroni & Cheese: $3.59
- French Fries: $4.19
- Red Skin Smashed Potatoes: $4.19
- Market Vegetables: $4.79
- Breakfast Potatoes: $5.49
- Hashbrowns: $5.49
- Backburner Soup: $5.89
- …and 11 more under $10. See the full menu below.
How Polly's Pies Compares
| Chain | Typical item price | Cheapest main | Items tracked | Updated |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cotton Patch | $8.40 | Small Fried Fish Basket $14.40 | 85 | July 2026 |
| Marlow's Tavern | $8.70 | Very Veggie Burger $14.80 | 130 | July 2026 |
| Hopcat | $9.15 | Fiesta Quesadilla (VT) $13.75 | 101 | July 2026 |
| O'Charley's Restaurant And Bar | $9.99 | Overloaded Potato Soup $4.99 | 58 | July 2026 |
| Romano's Macaroni Grill | $10.50 | Signature mac + cheese $15.00 | 15 | July 2026 |
| Polly's Pies | $11.19 | Banberry Slice $7.09 | 162 | July 2026 |
| Dave & Buster's | $11.69 | 5-Cheese Flatbread $14.99 | 96 | July 2026 |
| Cheddar's | $11.99 | Classic Cheeseburger $14.49 | 89 | July 2026 |
Prices are from each chain's benchmark location; see each page for full menus. And 33 more casual dining chains.
Full Polly's Pies Menu
All-American Classics | Whole Pies | Starters | Soups & Salads | Sandwiches | Burgers | Homestyle Meals | Skillets & Omelettes | Polly's Jr | Sides | Weekday Breakfast Specials | Breakfast Specialties | Pancakes & French Toast | Classic Egg Combos | Breakfast Sides | Pie Slices & Shakes | Bakery and Marketplace | Drinks
All-American Classics
| Item | Price |
|---|---|
| Famous Tuna SaladWhite albacore tuna, chopped eggs, sweet onions, relish, celery, lettuce, and mayo on our white bread. | $15.39 |
| PollyburgerOur signature beef patty atop fresh lettuce, pickles,and sweet onions. Served on our freshly baked bun ofyour choice spread with Ms. Polly’s Special Dressing. | $15.39 |
| Old Fashioned Chicken SaladGrilled chicken, walnuts, celery, sweet onions, relish, lettuce, and mayo on our grilled raisin walnut bread. | $15.39 |
| Pie of the Month – Banberry PieA timeless Polly’s favorite since 1975, our Banberry Pie features Ms. Polly’s signature banana cream filling, topped with fresh, sweet strawberries and finished with a perfect ring of real whipped cream. It’s the perfect slice of nostalgia – creamy, fruity, and beautifully balanced. On sale for the month of August only! | $17.69 |
| Banberry SliceMs. Polly's delicious banana cream filling, topped with fresh sweet strawberries and a ring of real whipped cream. | $7.09 |
The cheapest All-American Classics item is the Banberry Slice at $7.09. Prices run to $17.69 across 5 priced items at this Orange location.
Whole Pies
| Item | Price |
|---|---|
| Fresh PeachVine-ripened freestone peaches coated in a sweet glaze, nestled in our renowned buttery, flaky pie crust. | $28.39 |
| Chocolate CreamDeep rich chocolate, made from egg custard and cocoa, topped with whipped cream. | $22.49 |
| Apple CrispTart granny smith apples, delicately flavored with our own special blend of spices, covered with a sweet crumbly topping! | $24.79 |
| Banana CreamPlump fresh bananas lavished in creamy vanilla custard and topped with whipped cream and almonds. | $22.49 |
| BoysenberryLuscious boysenberries, chock full of tangy flavor. | $28.39 |
| Fruit CheesecakeOur classic cheesecake with a sweet strawberry topping. | $36.59 |
| Key LimeA traditional graham-cracker crust and a rich, tart filling made with Florida Key lime juice, topped with dollops of house-made whipped cream and fresh lime wheels. | $27.19 |
| Banberry – No Sugar AddedMs. Polly's delicious banana cream filling, topped with fresh sweet strawberries and a ring of real whipped cream. Made with Splenda sugar substitute. | $25.99 |
| CherryRed, tart and juicy cherries from Utah or Michigan, captured in one of Polly's original pies. | $22.49 |
| Chocolate SilkSilky chocolate baked in our famous pie crust and topped with real whipped cream and chocolate shavings. | $29.49 |
| Fresh StrawberryFresh strawberries covered in a sweet glaze on top of our freshly baked pie crust. | $28.39 |
| Fresh Strawberry – No Sugar AddedFresh strawberries covered in a sweet glaze on top of our freshly baked pie crust. Made with Splenda sugar substitute. | $29.49 |
| Famous Apple – No Sugar AddedTart granny smith apples, delicately flavored with our own special blend of spices. Made with Splenda sugar substitute. | $23.59 |
| Coconut CreamThe finest shredded Hawaiian Coconut is drenched in rich old-fashioned custard topped with whipped cream. | $22.49 |
| CheesecakeClassic cream cheese baked on a graham cracker crust. | $33.09 |
| Lemon MeringueLots of tasty lemon filling with a mountain of toasted meringue. | $21.29 |
| Bake at Home PeachOld fashioned country-kitchen flavor enhanced with a touch of cinnamon. | $21.29 |
| Bake at Home RhubarbOnly the finest Northwestern rhubarb. Polly's has created a unique pie with a tangy sweet-sour taste. | $21.29 |
| Bake at Home ApricotA famous recipe of sun-ripened apricots, flavored to perfection and bursting with golden goodness. | $21.29 |
| Bake at Home BlueberryMounds of wild mountain and cultivated blueberries for old time flavor. | $21.29 |
| POTM Banberry PieA timeless Polly’s favorite since 1975, our Banberry Pie features Ms. Polly’s signature banana cream filling, topped with fresh, sweet strawberries and finished with a perfect ring of real whipped cream. It’s the perfect slice of nostalgia – creamy, fruity, and beautifully balanced. | $17.69 |
| Pie of the Month – Apple PieJuly ONLY, we are thrilled to offer you an incredible deal featuring our Famous Apple Pie, made with tart Granny Smith apples and delicately infused with our unique blend of spices. | $17.69 |
| Banana Cream – No Sugar AddedPlump fresh bananas lavished in creamy vanilla custard and topped with whipped cream and almonds, made with Splenda sugar substitute. | $23.59 |
| Fresh Peach – No Sugar Added | $29.49 |
| Bake at Home Cherry – No Sugar AddedRed, tart and juicy cherries from Utah or Michigan, captured in one of Polly's original pies, made with Splenda sugar substitute. Frozen & ready to bake! | $22.49 |
The POTM Banberry Pie is the lowest-priced Whole Pies item at $17.69 at this Orange location. The 25 priced items range up to $36.59.
Starters
| Item | Price |
|---|---|
| Southern Pimento Cheese DipHouse-made chilled dip topped with green onions, served with fresh cucumbers, carrots, and sliced baguette | $9.49 |
| Beer-Battered Onion RingsSteak-cut sweet onions with our Comeback Sauce. | $10.09 |
| Mozzarella SticksWith marinara sauce. | $10.69 |
The cheapest Starters item is the Southern Pimento Cheese Dip at $9.49. The 3 priced items top out at $10.69 at this Orange location.
Soups & Salads
| Item | Price |
|---|---|
| Bleu Cheese WedgeIceberg wedge with cherrywood smoked bacon, bleu cheese crumbles, grape tomatoes, house-made bleu cheese dressing, and green onions. | $8.29 |
| Backburner SoupA Polly’s Classic – steam kettle slow-cooked with bacon, ham, pinto and black beans, garden vegetables, and small pasta shells. | $5.89 |
| Asian Chicken SaladGrilled chicken, shredded lettuce, red cabbage, carrots, sliced cucumbers, mandarin oranges, toasted almonds and Ginger-Sesame dressing, topped with crispy wontons, sesame seeds, and green onions. | $18.89 |
| House SaladSliced cucumber, tomato, carrots, red onion, and our own croutons. | $7.09 |
| Caesar SaladCrisp mixed greens, house-made croutons, and shaved Parmesan cheese in a zesty Caesar dressing. Served with our garlic Parmesan toast. | $12.99 |
| Creamy Tomato Basil SoupOur comforting creamy tomato basil soup, made with a unique blend of red ripe tomatoes, rich cream, garlic, and basil, topped with shredded parmesan and a hand cut seasoned crouton (vegetarian) | $5.89 |
| Turkey CobbShredded lettuce tossed with house-made bleu cheese dressing, topped with layers of diced turkey, tomatoes, applewood smoked bacon, bleu cheese crumbles, shredded carrots, hard boiled egg, green onion, and sliced avocado. | $18.89 |
| Crispy Chicken SaladHand-breaded crispy chicken breast served warm on a bed of fresh iceberg and romaine lettuce tossed with applewood smoked bacon, Cheddar cheese, tomatoes, green onions, and hard boiled egg in a honey mustard dressing. | $20.09 |
The cheapest Soups & Salads item is the Backburner Soup at $5.89, and prices reach $20.09 across 8 priced items at this Orange location.
Sandwiches
| Item | Price |
|---|---|
| King Edward's ClubSlices of oven roasted turkey breast, applewood smoked bacon, avocado, lettuce, tomato, and mayo on our freshly baked toasted sourdough bread. | $18.89 |
| Half Sandwich ComboHalf sandwich with your choice of a cup of soup or a dinner salad. Choose from: Chicken Salad, Garlic Aioli Turkey, Tuna Salad, Mega Grilled Cheese, Avocado & Friends | $15.39 |
| Mega Grilled CheeseJack, Cheddar, Swiss, and American on our sourdoughbread grilled with Ms. Polly’s special garlic Parmesanspread. | $14.19 |
| Avocado & FriendsSliced avocado, tomatoes, cucumber, sweet onions,green leaf lettuce, Jack or vegan Gouda cheese andgarlic aioli on our kracked wheat bread. | $14.19 |
| Prime Rib French DipSlow-roasted prime rib piled on a baguette with creamy horseradish aioli and served with au jus for dipping. | $20.09 |
| Garlic Aioli Roasted TurkeySlices of oven roasted Foster Farms® turkey breast,garlic aioli, tomatoes, lettuce, and Jack Cheese servedon our sourdough bread. | $16.59 |
| California Tuna MeltChilled white albacore tuna salad**, fresh avocado, tomato, lettuce, mayo, and melted Cheddar on our grilled sourdough bread. | $16.59 |
| Comeback Chicken SandwichHand-breaded fried chicken breast, freshly baked white bun, pickle chips, lettuce, and our house-made ‘Comeback Sauce’. | $15.39 |
The cheapest Sandwiches item is the Mega Grilled Cheese at $14.19. Prices run to $20.09 across 8 priced items at this Orange location.
Burgers
| Item | Price |
|---|---|
| Polly CheeseburgerOur signature beef patty covered in your choice of melted cheese atop fresh lettuce, pickles, and sweet onion. Served on our freshly baked bun of your choice spread with Ms. Polly’s Special Dressing. | $16.59 |
| Grilled Sourdough BurgerOur sourdough bread grilled with garlic Parmesanbutter, grilled onions, Cheddar cheese, lettuce,tomato, pickles and Ms. Polly’s Special Dressing. | $16.59 |
| PollymeltOur signature 6 oz beef patty smothered in grilled sweet onions and your choice of melted Swiss or Cheddar cheese. Served on our grilled Rye bread, back by popular demand! | $16.59 |
| Create Your Own BurgerCraft your ideal burger by selecting your preferred protein, bun, and sauce. You can also enhance it with extras like arugula or caramelized onions for only 59 cents. And don’t forget the cheese! Each burger includes pickles and lettuce, served with either fries or coleslaw. For an upgrade, enjoy sweet potato fries or onion rings for an additional $1.99. | $15.39 |
The Create Your Own Burger is the lowest-priced Burgers item at $15.39 at this Orange location. The 4 priced items range up to $16.59.
Homestyle Meals
| Item | Price |
|---|---|
| Traditional Roasted Turkey DinnerOven roasted turkey breast, homestyle stuffing, red skinsmashed potatoes, green beans*, our cranberry sauce.and turkey gravy. | $22.49 |
| Chicken Pie DinnerPolly’s pie crust with light meat chicken, signature gravy,broccoli, celery, cauliflower, carrots, peas, sweet onions,and diced potatoes. Served with red skin smashedpotatoes, and our cranberry sauce. | $18.89 |
| Classic MeatloafHouse-made meatloaf blended with Jack cheese, bell peppers, and sweet onions topped with tomato ketchup glaze and ladled with rich demi glace. Served with market vegetables and red-skin smashed potatoes with rich demi-glace. | $21.29 |
| Country Fried SteakCountry chicken fried steak with country gravy, red skinsmashed potatoes, and green beans*. | $18.89 |
| Salisbury SteakPolly’s housemade steak with freshly grilled mushrooms,rich demi-glace, red skin smashed potatoes, and greenbeans*. | $18.89 |
| Chicken Caliente PenneGrilled chicken sautéed with onion, bell pepper, tomato, and garlic then tossed with penne pasta in chipotle cream sauce and topped with cilantro. Served with garlic Parmesan sourdough toast. | $21.29 |
| Grilled Norwegian SalmonAtlantic salmon filet served with market vegetables and herb rice. Prepared with your choice of: garlic butter and lemon or Cajun seasoning with chipotle butter. | $23.59 |
| Creamy Shrimp PastaSautéed shrimp tossed with penne pasta in a garlic Parmesan cream sauce. Served with garlic Parmesan sourdough toast. | $21.29 |
| New York Steak DinnerJuicy, tender steak seared to order, paired with red-skin smashed potatoes and market vegetables. | $28.39 |
| Garlic Lemon Grilled ChickenTender grilled chicken breast topped with a buttery Chardonnay herb sauce, served with fresh herb rice and seasonal market vegetables. | $18.89 |
The cheapest Homestyle Meals item is the Chicken Pie Dinner at $18.89. The 10 priced items top out at $28.39 at this Orange location.
Skillets & Omelettes
| Item | Price |
|---|---|
| Create Your Own OmeletteCreate your perfect omelette by choosing two of your favorite vegetables. For an upgrade, consider adding meat and cheese. This delicious meal also includes a selection of breakfast potatoes and a bakery item of your choice. | $16.59 |
| A.B.C. OmeletteAvocado, cherrywood smoked bacon, cheddar cheese, mushrooms and green onions | $20.09 |
| Vegetable OmeletteA blend of market vegetables and melted cheese with a side of salsa. | $17.69 |
| Have It All SkilletEggs scrambled with cherrywood smoked bacon, slicedsausage, onions, mushrooms, bell peppers, and Jack cheese tossed with our signature breakfast potatoes. | $20.09 |
The cheapest Skillets & Omelettes item is the Create Your Own Omelette at $16.59, and prices reach $20.09 across 4 priced items at this Orange location.
Polly's Jr
| Item | Price |
|---|---|
| Polly's Famous Cookie | $1.79 |
| French Toast Dippers & EggServed with syrup for dipping. Served with choice of one sausage link, one bacon strip, fresh fruit cup, or hashbrowns. | $7.09 |
| Mini Pancakes & EggServed with butter & syrup. Add some extra love to your pancakes! Add Chocolate Chips, Blueberries, or Sliced Bananas 1.00 each. Served with choice of one sausage link, one bacon strip, fresh fruit cup, or hashbrowns. | $7.09 |
| Jr Pasta with Red SauceCavatappi pasta with red sauce topped with parmesan cheese. Includes choice of one Jr. side. | $7.69 |
| Butter NoodlesServed plain or with butter & parmesan. Includes choice of one Jr. side. | $7.69 |
| Jr Chicken TendersWith your choice of dipping sauce. Includes choice of one Jr. side. | $7.09 |
| Egg & ToastWith our own tasty Bumbleberry Jam. Served with choice of one sausage link, one bacon strip, fresh fruit cup, or hashbrowns. | $7.09 |
| Mini Corn DogsThe perfect finger food! Served with ketchup for dipping. Includes choice of one Jr. side. | $7.69 |
| Pollyburger JrOur mini fresh beef patty served on a freshly baked roll. Includes choice of one Jr. side. | $7.69 |
| Jr Mac & CheeseHot and cheesy! Includes choice of one Jr. side. | $7.69 |
| Polly's Jr Grilled CheeseOn our freshly baked grilled sourdough bread. Includes choice of one Jr. side. | $7.69 |
| Silly Face PancakeUse our fresh fruit to make your own silly face" pancake. | $5.89 |
| Polly Cheeseburger JrOur mini fresh beef patty served on a freshly baked roll. Includes choice of one Jr. side. | $8.29 |
The cheapest Polly's Jr item is the Polly's Famous Cookie at $1.79. Prices run to $8.29 across 13 priced items at this Orange location.
Sides
| Item | Price |
|---|---|
| Red Skin Smashed Potatoes | $4.19 |
| French Fries | $4.19 |
| Macaroni & Cheese | $3.59 |
| Sweet Potato Fries | $5.89 |
| Polly's Coleslaw | $3.29 |
| Fruit Cup | $3.59 |
| Green Beans | $3.29 |
| Market Vegetables | $4.79 |
The Polly's Coleslaw is the lowest-priced Sides item at $3.29 at this Orange location. The 8 priced items range up to $5.89.
Weekday Breakfast Specials
| Item | Price |
|---|---|
| 1-1-1 ComboOne buttermilk pancake, one large egg, and one bacon or sausage | $9.49 |
| Country ComboButtermilk biscuit, sausage country gravy, two eggs any style, and a fresh fruit cup. | $12.99 |
| Early Riser BreakfastTwo large eggs, two Jones Dairy Farms smoked sausage links or two strips of applewood smoked bacon, your choice of breakfast potatoes, and a daily bakery item. | $16.59 |
| Perfect Pancake BreakfastTwo sweet buttermilk pancakes, two large eggs, and two Jones Dairy Farms smoked sausage links or two strips of applewood smoked bacon. | $14.19 |
| French Toast ComboTwo slices of French toast, two large eggs, and two Jones Dairy Farms smoked sausage links or two strips of applewood smoked bacon. | $16.59 |
| Avocado & Egg ToastOur freshly baked toasted sourdough bread with smashed avocado, sliced tomato, two eggs, and a side of salsa. Served with a fresh fruit cup. | $11.79 |
The cheapest Weekday Breakfast Specials item is the 1-1-1 Combo at $9.49. The 6 priced items top out at $16.59 at this Orange location.
Breakfast Specialties
| Item | Price |
|---|---|
| Breakfast SandwichFreshly baked grilled sourdough bread, bacon or sausage, golden hashbrowns, scrambled eggs, mayo, and melted cheddar cheese. | $15.39 |
| Polly's Breakfast BurritoExtra large flour tortilla stuffed with bacon orsausage, scrambled eggs, hashbrowns, peppers,onions, shredded jack cheese, sour cream, salsaverde, and smashed avocado. | $17.69 |
| Avocado Toast w/ EggOur freshly baked toasted sourdough bread with smashed avocado, sliced tomato, two eggs, and a side of salsa. | $15.99 |
| Quiche BreakfastA slice of our freshly baked quiche, served with a fresh fruit cup and breakfast potatoes.Quiche Lorraine* or Spinach & Feta (both contain mushrooms) | $18.89 |
The cheapest Breakfast Specialties item is the Breakfast Sandwich at $15.39, and prices reach $18.89 across 4 priced items at this Orange location.
Pancakes & French Toast
| Item | Price |
|---|---|
| Double Buttermilk PancakesTwo sweet buttermilk pancakes served with butter& syrup. | $16.59 |
| Ms. Polly's Triple Breakfast SurpriseThree sweet buttermilk pancakes served withbutter, syrup, three large eggs, a choice of threeJones Dairy Farms smoked sausage links or threecherrywood smoked bacon strips, and your choiceof breakfast potatoes. | $20.69 |
| French Toast ComboTwo slices of Ms. Polly's freshly baked breaddrenched in our special egg batter and grilled untilgolden brown. | $15.99 |
| Banana Macadamia Nut PancakesTwo sweet banana-packed pancakes topped withreal whipped cream and roasted HawaiianMacadamia nuts. | $17.09 |
The cheapest Pancakes & French Toast item is the French Toast Combo at $15.99. Prices run to $20.69 across 4 priced items at this Orange location.
Classic Egg Combos
| Item | Price |
|---|---|
| Chicken Fried Steak & EggsChicken fried steak smothered in country gravy andserved with two large eggs, your choice ofbreakfast potatoes | $20.09 |
| 2-3-1 ComboServed with two large eggs, three Jones DairyFarms smoked sausage links or three cherrywoodsmoked bacon strips, and your choice of breakfastpotatoes. | $17.09 |
| Eggs & PotatoesTwo large eggs and your choice of breakfastpotatoes | $12.39 |
| One Egg ComboOne large egg, two Jones Dairy Farms smokedsausage links or two cherrywood smoked baconstrips, and your choice of breakfast potatoes | $12.39 |
| New York Steak & EggsJuicy, tender steak seared to order served with two large eggs and your choice of breakfast potatoes. | $25.99 |
| Ham Steak & EggsGrilled ham steak served with two large eggs and your choice of breakfast potatoes. | $18.89 |
The Eggs & Potatoes is the lowest-priced Classic Egg Combos item at $12.39 at this Orange location. The 6 priced items range up to $25.99.
Breakfast Sides
| Item | Price |
|---|---|
| Sausage (3) | $7.09 |
| Biscuit & Gravy | $5.89 |
| Hashbrowns | $5.49 |
| Breakfast Potatoes | $5.49 |
| Fresh Fruit | $3.59 |
| Cottage Cheese | $3.59 |
| Bacon (3) | $7.09 |
| Cornbread | $3.59 |
The cheapest Breakfast Sides item is the Fresh Fruit at $3.59. The 8 priced items top out at $7.09 at this Orange location.
Pie Slices & Shakes
| Item | Price |
|---|---|
| Fresh Peach SliceVine-ripened freestone peaches coated in a sweet glaze, nestled in our renowned buttery, flaky pie crust. | $7.69 |
| Apple Crisp SliceTart granny smith apples, delicately flavored with our own special blend of spices, covered with a sweet crumbly topping! | $7.09 |
| Chocolate Cream SliceDeep rich chocolate, made from egg custard and cocoa, topped with whipped cream. | $6.49 |
| Boysenberry SliceLuscious boysenberries, chock full of tangy flavor. | $7.69 |
| Banana Cream SlicePlump fresh bananas lavished in creamy vanilla custard and topped with whipped cream and almonds. | $6.49 |
| Coconut Cream SliceThe finest shredded Hawaiian Coconut is drenched in rich old-fashioned custard topped with whipped cream. | $6.49 |
| Cherry SliceRed, tart and juicy cherries from Utah or Michigan, captured in one of Polly's original pies. | $6.49 |
| Lemon Meringue SliceLots of tasty lemon filling with a mountain of toasted meringue. | $6.49 |
| Apple SliceTart granny smith apples, delicately flavored with our own special blend of spices. | $6.49 |
| Apple Slice – No Sugar AddedTart granny smith apples, delicately flavored with our own special blend of spices. Made with equal sugar substitute. | $7.09 |
| Fresh Strawberry SliceFresh strawberries covered in a sweet glaze on top of our freshly baked pie crust. | $7.69 |
| Fresh Strawberry Slice – No Sugar AddedFresh strawberries covered in a sweet glaze on top of our freshly baked pie crust. Made with equal sugar substitute. | $8.29 |
| Key Lime SliceA traditional graham-cracker crust and a rich, tart filling made with Florida Key lime juice topped with a ring of real whipped cream. | $7.09 |
The cheapest Pie Slices & Shakes item is the Chocolate Cream Slice at $6.49, and prices reach $8.29 across 13 priced items at this Orange location.
Bakery and Marketplace
| Item | Price |
|---|---|
| Giant Cinnamon Rolls 2ct | $10.69 |
| Snickerdoodle CookiesPolly’s famous cookies baked fresh every day in our Big Red Oven. | $2.19 |
| Oatmeal CookiesPolly’s famous cookies baked fresh every day in our Big Red Oven. | $2.19 |
| Chocolate Chip CookiesPolly’s famous cookies baked fresh every day in our Big Red Oven. | $2.19 |
| Peanut Butter Chocolate ChipPolly’s famous cookies baked fresh every day in our Big Red Oven. | $2.19 |
| Muffin 4ct | $12.99 |
| Cornbread pan | $8.29 |
| Biscuits 6ct | $7.09 |
| French Baguette | $3.59 |
| Sourdough Loaf | $7.09 |
| Bumbleberry JamThe perfect mix of blueberries, strawberries, and blackberries in a sweet and tart jam. Best served with our baked fresh daily biscuits or on toast! | $12.99 |
| Dinner Rolls 12ct | $9.49 |
| Raisin Walnut Loaf | $9.49 |
| White Loaf | $5.89 |
| Kracked Wheat Loaf | $8.29 |
| 1lb Polly's Coffee Bag | $17.69 |
| Strawberry JamOur Fresh strawberries are made into the perfect sweet jam. Best served with our baked fresh daily biscuits or on toast! | $11.19 |
| White Buns, 6 packFreshly baked white burger buns, perfect for BBQs, sloppy joes, and beyond, adding a touch of softness and flavor to take your grilling game to the next level! | $7.09 |
| Wheat Buns, 6 packFreshly baked kracked wheat burger buns, perfect for BBQs, sloppy joes, and beyond, adding a touch of softness and flavor to take your grilling game to the next level! | $7.09 |
The cheapest Bakery and Marketplace item is the Snickerdoodle Cookies at $2.19. Prices run to $17.69 across 19 priced items at this Orange location.
Drinks
| Item | Price |
|---|---|
| Polly's Gourmet Coffee | $4.79 |
| Freshly Brewed Mango Iced Tea | $4.79 |
| Vanilla Cream Cold Brew Coffee | $6.29 |
| Orange Juice | $5.29 |
| Freshly Brewed Ice Tea | $4.79 |
| Soda | $4.79 |
| Lemonade | $4.79 |
| Cranberry Juice | $5.09 |
| Polly Palmer | $5.29 |
| Strawberry Lemonade | $5.29 |
| Hot Chocolate | $4.79 |
| Arnold Palmer | $5.89 |
| Apple Juice | $5.09 |
| Shirley Temple | $5.09 |
The Polly's Gourmet Coffee is the lowest-priced Drinks item at $4.79 at this Orange location. The 14 priced items range up to $6.29.
Frequently Asked Questions
How much is the Chicken Caliente Penne at Polly's Pies?
The Chicken Caliente Penne costs $21.29 at Polly's Pies as of July 2026 – one of 10 items in the Homestyle Meals section.
What is the cheapest meal-worthy item at Polly's Pies?
Setting aside condiments, drinks and extras, the cheapest meal-worthy item on the Polly's Pies menu is the Banberry Slice at $7.09 as of July 2026.
What is the price range at Polly's Pies?
Prices on the Polly's Pies menu run from $1.79 to $36.59 as of July 2026, counting everything on the page from single sides up to family-size and catering orders, and half the priced items are $11.19 or less.
How many items are on the Polly's Pies menu?
The Polly's Pies menu we track lists 162 items across 18 sections as of July 2026.
Does Polly's Pies have a value menu?
Yes: 26 items under $10 as of July 2026, starting with the Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip at $2.19. See the value list above.
Polly’s Pies Menu PDF
Download the full Polly’s Pies menu with prices as a PDF: Polly’s Pies Menu Prices PDF (updated July 2026).
